Why Informal Family Loans Can Create Big Problems

Many families casually say, “It’s a loan—we’ll pay you back someday.” But unless the transaction is structured like a genuine loan, the IRS and the law may treat it as a gift, which comes with its own filing requirements and estate planning implications.

A valid, enforceable loan must meet specific requirements.

This is why it is so important to create clarity while you are alive. Clear documentation today prevents conflict, confusion, and legal complications in the future.

---

What Makes a Loan a “Real” Loan?

If you want a financial transfer to be treated as an actual loan, there are several legal elements that must be in place and followed. A loan is not a loan simply because you call it one. It must function like a loan.

At minimum, a legitimate intra-family loan should include:

• A written promissory note signed by the borrower

• A stated interest rate at or above the IRS-required Applicable Federal Rate (AFR)

• Clear terms describing repayment schedules, maturity dates, and whether there is a balloon payment

The AFR changes monthly and applies differently depending on the loan term (short-, mid-, or long-term). Anyone can look up the current AFR by searching “IRS AFR rate” online.

If these requirements are not followed, the IRS can reclassify the transfer as a gift, which may require filing a gift tax return and may reduce the lender’s lifetime gift and estate tax exemption.

---

Should the Loan Be Forgiven at Death—or Count Against an Inheritance?

Many parents loan children money with the hope or expectation of being repaid, but they also want to treat their children fairly at death. That’s why it is essential to decide how you want the loan treated in your estate plan.

There are generally two approaches:

Reduce the child’s inheritance.
If the loan is outstanding at the parent’s death, the unpaid balance reduces that child’s share. For example:
If their inheritance is $200,000 and they still owe $20,000, they would receive $180,000.

Forgive the loan entirely.
Some parents prefer to forgive the remaining balance as a final gift.

If this is your intention, your will or trust must explicitly say so. Otherwise, the personal representative or trustee must legally attempt to collect the debt—even if that isn’t what you want.

A related issue arises if the child who borrowed the money passes away before the parent. You must decide whether the reduction (or forgiveness) applies to their children (your grandchildren) or whether their branch of the family should receive a full share unaffected by the loan. Your estate plan must clearly reflect your wishes.

When It Isn’t a Loan—It’s a Gift

If you do not intend to charge interest, collect payments, or follow loan formalities, then the transfer is a gift—not a loan. Gifts have different legal consequences, different tax requirements, and must be documented properly to avoid problems later.

Family loans can be incredibly helpful, but they can also complicate your estate if they are not structured correctly. The best time to document your intentions—and protect your family—is before money changes hands.

If you want to make sure your estate plan properly addresses loans, gifts, inheritances, and tax consequences, we’re here to help.

Frequently Asked Questions

 

What happens to a family loan if the parent dies before it’s repaid?

If the loan is not properly structured, it may become a probate asset and the estate may need to attempt collection. With proper planning, the loan can be managed through the revocable trust and handled according to your instructions.

Do I have to charge interest on a loan to my child?

Yes. To avoid the transaction being reclassified as a gift, you must charge at least the IRS Applicable Federal Rate (AFR). Otherwise, the IRS may impose gift tax consequences.

Will a forgiven loan affect how much my other children inherit?

It depends on what your will or trust says. Your estate plan should explicitly state whether the loan is forgiven at death or whether it reduces that child’s share to maintain fairness.

Author

Claire creates wills and trusts which provide security and peace of mind. She compassionately listens to her clients’ dreams, goals, and fears and then fashions plans that best meet their needs. It is important to Claire that her clients understand different options and make decisions that are right for them. She loves to educate clients by drawing out complicated concepts.

Come visit us! Conveniently located in Rochester, Minnesota.